Tanning With Oil Or Tanning Lotion – Which One is Better?


We all crave for the perfect tan. The dark yet even tan that will remain in your skin for days.

However, who has the time to stay in the sun for hours to get a natural tan?

Not to mention, staying in the sun for hours can be harmful to the skin. What to do, then?

The simple solution is getting a fake tan. The experience can be pretty fun and useful, especially since it does not require you to stay in the sun for long hours and wait for the tan to come.

Instead, let the tan come to you while you are relaxing and enjoying it!

Tanning with oil or Tanning Lotion? Which one is better?

Now that you have decided to get a fake tan, you need to choose whether you will use tanning oil or lotion to get it. The decision is not as easy as it sounds!

There are many things to contemplate to decide which one would be right. So how to choose? Are you panicking already thinking you need to research a lot?

Fear not!

Go ahead and read the article. Then you will know all you need to before deciding whether tanning with oil or tanning lotion would be better for you.

Why should you use tanning oil?

Although tanning oils are trendy all over the world, you may still question why you should stick to using it, or if you are a new user, you may be wondering if it’s worth a try after all!

With this dilemma in mind, here we are going to talk about what is so special about tanning with oil.

Firstly, you should know that tanning oils will work not only to give you the brown shade you want, but it will also take care of your skin.

The elements in oils work altogether to keep skin hydrated and nourished.

Almost all of us have complained once or twice about not getting an even tan through the sunlight. We have all been there, right?

Well, the good news is that tanning oils will give you faster, deeper, and even tan.

Not only that, but the oils can also reach and spread tan in places otherwise cannot be reached. So, there’s that!

Finally, tanning with oil will also keep your skin young! Don’t believe us? The fact is, tanning oils contain vitamin E, coconut oil, botanical extracts, etc. that will shield your skin against getting old.

Why should you use tanning lotion?

If you are pondering whether you should give tanning with lotions a try, you have come to the right place! Keep reading to find out what is so special about tanning lotion.

You will be delighted knowing that this lotion is pretty useful for self-tanning since it’s so easy to apply! Hence, there is a pretty small room for mistakes while using.

Therefore, even if you have no experience of tanning lotion beforehand, no need to worry!

Along with that, the DHA in the lotion creates a fake yet even tan in the skin.

When using tanning lotion, you do not need to sit in the sun for hours to get a natural tan. Therefore, your skin will not be at risk of getting wrinkles or skin cancer.

Moreover, you will be getting a lot of compliments on your natural tan that’s for sure!

The benefits of tanning lotions do not end here. The elements in tanning lotions contain vitamin e, fruit extracts, antioxidants, etc. which will keep your skin hydrated and conditioned.

The best part is, tanning lotion will not feel greasy at all!

Comparison between tanning oil and tanning lotion in the perspective of the user’s benefit

Now that you know what is so special about both tanning with oil and tanning lotion, it is bound to get even more confusing! What if both options seem efficient, and now you are more confused than ever?

Well, we firmly believe we have just the thing you need.

To ease your confusion regarding making a choice, here we are going to compare the two options, all from your point of view, obviously!

After all, everything we are doing here is to benefit you so that you make the right choice for you! After all, when it comes to skin, you need to be extra careful!

Tanning Oil vs Tanning Lotion

To begin with, the main difference between tanning oil and lotion lies inconsistency. As you can probably already guess, the texture of tanning oil will be denser and, in many cases, greasier than the feel of tanning lotions.

You can even feel the difference in your skin after applying the product. For instance, the tanning lotion will not feel heavy on the skin, but your skin will feel oily after putting tanning oil on it.

In addition to that, your skin will appear shinier if you go with tanning oil!

It happens because your skin can absorb the lotion pretty fast after applying.

On the flip side, the ingredients of the tanning oils do not let the skin absorb the oil that faster. As a result, you will have a different experience with each product.

There is another thing to consider here. You need to remember your purpose in using the products. What are you looking for? Do you want a dark, bronze tan, or would you be happy with a lighter shade of brown?

The purpose is crucial since it can be a deal-breaker in some cases. Let us demonstrate. For instance, in case you are craving for a dark tan that will remain for a more extended period, you should go for tanning oils rather than a lotion.

Why may you ask?

Well, tanning oils do not contain a higher amount of SPF. Also, since they are less likely to get absorbed easily onto skin, they will remain on the skin for hours and thus working its charm on your skin.

As a result, you are more likely to end up with a dark and longer-lasting tan. Therefore, we recommend using tanning oil if you have dark skin or already a nice base tan or you want a dark tan.

On the other hand, tanning lotions contain a higher level of SPF, and they will be absorbed by your skin quickly. Hence, the lotion will not be on your skin for hours, and the tan will not be as dark.

We strongly suggest you go for tanning lotions initially at least until your skin gets used to being out in the sun and eventually achieve a nice base tan.

Another significant difference between these two lies in smell. Usually, tanning oils contain all-natural elements and oils, which result in a very nice, in some cases, tropical aroma.

Conversely, although tanning lotions do smell pleasant, they may not give off that natural or tropical scent as tanning oils.

Besides, applying tanning lotions on your body is just like using any other lotion. There is no difference in the process of putting it in, whatsoever!

As a result, there is a small room for making errors. Therefore, even if you are a beginner at this, there is no need to worry!

However, applying tanning oil correctly on the body needs more effort than tanning lotion. Hence, it is easy to under or overuse the oil, especially if you are a new user.

But there is no need to stress too much about this. Usually, users’ directions are already mentioned in the container. As long as you follow the procedure, you should be fine!


What’s reassuring is that both tanning oils and lotions will work to keep your skin hydrated and moisturized no matter which one you choose. The components of the tanning products usually contain skin nourishing products that help to keep the skin’s condition at bay.

Along with all these, tanning products also make sure you get an even tan. Since most of us face problems related to uneven tan, it is relieving to know that tanning products can solve that problem in only one use!

Moreover, in general, both tanning products contain more or less level of SPF to protect against sunburn, although the extent and effectiveness vary from product to product.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do tanning oils work?

Well, as we all know, in most sunny climates, our skin receives sufficient UV exposure to produce a brown shade. In fact, tanning oils use this natural process as its base. What the oils do is that firstly they draw the sun’s UV rays, and then they focus the beams onto the skin. In summary, the indigents of the tanning oils work to amplify the rays and then speed up the process of natural tanning.

What does tanning oils do?

There are certain functions of tanning oil. For instance:

  • Gets you a faster and an even tan
    • Some provide additional sun protection.
    • Nourishes skin
    • Contains antioxidant properties that soothe skin
    • some also carry anti-aging properties
    • Works to heal damaged skin

Is tanning oil bad for you?

Well, that depends. Tanning with oil will not be bad for your skin if you are not allergic to any of the ingredients of the oil you are using. Nonetheless, in general, tanning oils do not carry any or very little sunscreen.

As a result, the tanning oils alone would not be sufficient to protect your skin against the ultraviolet radiation of the sun. Hence, we strongly recommend you to use tanning oil coupled with sunscreen. It is better to put sunscreen first and then apply the tanning oil.

Which tanning oil is the best?

Although there are many options available in the market, all claiming to be the best ones, the ultimate experience can be pretty subjective. Nevertheless, no need to worry! As we have made up a list of the top 10 best tanning oils in the market just for you!

  • Hawaiian Tropic Dark Tanning Oil
  • Panama Jack Amplifier Oil
  • Isabella’s Gold Best Natural Bronzing Tanning Oil
  • Sun Bum Moisturizing Tanning Oil
  • Banana Boat Ultramist Deep Tanning Oil
  • Maui Babe Browning Lotion Check Price
  • Sky Organics Fractionated Coconut Tanning Oil
  • Australian Gold Bronzing Dry Tanning Oil Spray
  • Alba Botanica Hawaiian Coconut Dry Tanning Oil heck Price
  • Ed Hardy Coconut Kisses Golden Tanning Oil

What are the contrasts between tanning oil and tanning lotion?

Even though there are many dissimilarities between tanning oil and tanning lotion, there is one main difference between these two. That is the texture. Tanning oil is greasy, and it can feel heavier also oiler in the skin while the lotion will not. Besides, another difference is that tanning lotions usually carry a higher amount of SPF converse to tanning oils. In general, tanning oils contain very little to no amount of SPF.


To sum up, here we have used 100% authentic sources, reviews to make sure you feel like this article is a reliable one.

We have done our best to talk about all the essential aspects related to both tanning with oil and tanning lotion so that you do not have to browse through thousands of sites to find the information you need.

But you should know that the ultimate experience depends on you. After considering all the critical factors, if you feel like you have found a clear choice, do not hesitate. Go for it!

Leave a Comment